Deciding Between 8 Inch Vs. 10 Inch Mattresses

8 Inch Vs. 10 Inch MattressesImage source - craftmatic

Choosing the right mattress thickness can feel like a puzzle for many homeowners. Consider this: an 8-inch mattress is often lighter and more affordable, yet may not suit everyone’s needs.

This article will guide readers through the key differences between 8-inch and 10-inch mattresses, aiding them in making an informed choice that promises comfort and support. Let’s find your perfect sleep solution.

Key Takeaways – An important mattress thickness guide 

  • 8-inch mattresses are more affordable and firmer, making them suitable for lighter individuals or those who prefer a solid sleep surface. They are also easier to move due to their lightweight design.
  • 10-inch mattresses provide enhanced comfort with additional layers for better pressure relief, accommodating a wider range of body weights and sleeping positions. They generally have a longer lifespan but come at a higher cost and may be heavier to move.
  • The choice between mattress thickness should factor in weight limit, firmness preference, health benefits such as back support or joint pain relief, and whether the bed is meant for single adults, children, couples, or guest rooms.
  • Both mattress sizes have pros and cons: 8-inch mattresses might not offer enough cushioning for some sleepers while being perfect for bunk beds; 10-inch options offer balanced support but can be too soft for those needing a firmer surface.
  • When selecting the right mattress thickness, homeowners need to weigh personal needs like budget constraints against preferences around sleep comfort levels and consider long-term value in terms of durability and overall satisfaction.

Is a 10-inch or 8-inch mattress better?

When choosing between an 8-inch and a 10-inch mattress, it’s essential to consider factors such as material breakdown, comfort and support, durability, lifespan, and price point.

Each thickness has unique characteristics that may appeal to individuals based on their needs.

Material breakdown to understand how thick should a mattress be

Homeowners seeking the ideal mattress must understand the differences between 8-inch and 10-inch options, particularly regarding material composition.

Material Aspect 8 Inch Mattress 10 Inch Mattress
Layers Usually has fewer layers, often a base foam with a comfort layer on top Typically includes additional layers such as a transition layer for extra cushioning
Base Foam Thickness Generally thinner, providing a firmer feel A thicker base offers deeper compression support
Comfort Layer It may be less generous, resulting in a firmer sleeping surface An ample comfort layer contributes to a plush feel
Density Higher density for firmness and durability Varies, but can accommodate a range of densities for different comfort levels
Weight Accommodation Supports lighter individuals comfortably Better suited for a wider range of body weights
Body Contouring Offers minimal contouring Provides enhanced contouring and pressure relief
Overall Support Good for sleepers who prefer a firmer mattress Excellent for those seeking a balance of support and softness

An 8-inch mattress may suffice for petite individuals, while the 10-inch variant caters to diverse sleep preferences. Both options give homeowners distinct levels of comfort and support directly tied to their material makeup. The choice hinges on personal needs, sleep habits, and the desired balance between firmness and plushness.

Comfort and support

Having explored the materials that make up these mattresses, let’s focus on how they can affect your nightly rest. An 8-inch mattress often brings a firmer feel, which may be ideal for those who need extra support for their back and prefer a more solid sleeping surface. Also, ensure that you keep the type of the standard mattress in mind, such as a hybrid mattress, memory foam, etc.

On the other hand, a 10-inch mattress typically offers additional layers that enhance comfort by conforming to your body’s shape and providing pressure relief in key areas like hips and shoulders.

Choosing between an 8-inch or 10-inch mattress also hinges on personal comfort preferences. A slimmer mattress might suit petite individuals who enjoy a firmness level while wrapping them in enough memory foam to sleep soundly through the night.

Those seeking luxurious softness or with larger frames may find that thicker mattresses deliver better cushioning and overall nighttime support, ensuring quality sleep without compromising on comfort levels or waking up with aches and pains.

Durability and lifespan

Durability and lifespan are crucial factors when choosing the right mattress for your home. A 10-inch mattress often has multiple layers contributing to its longevity, providing a sturdy foundation for years of restful sleep.

These thicker mattresses can withstand more wear and tear due to their additional padding and support systems. In contrast, an 8-inch mattress might be ideal for those who prefer a firmer sleeping surface, but it could have a shorter lifespan because there’s less material to absorb daily strains.

The materials within an 8-inch or 10-inch memory foam mattress significantly affect durability. High-density foams in thicker mattresses resist sagging and maintain their shape longer than lower-density options in some slim mattresses.

Even though both thicknesses can accommodate many adults, considering the quality of construction will ensure you choose a comfortable, supportive, and long-lasting addition to your bedroom furniture assortment without compromising on sleep quality.

With durability accounted for, let’s move on to understand how pricing weighs into your decision-making process.

The price point to choose the right mattress thickness

The price point is critical for homeowners when choosing between an 8-inch and a 10-inch right mattress thickness. It reflects not only the initial cost but also the value over time.

Mattress Thickness Initial Cost Cost Over Time Value Proposition
8 Inch Mattress Typically less expensive It may need replacing sooner due to less material durability Cost-effective for short-term use or limited budgets
10 Inch Mattress Generally more expensive Potentially longer lifespan balances initial investment It is good value for those seeking a balance of comfort and durability

Homeowners should assess the upfront cost and consider the long-term investment. An 8-inch mattress typically costs less at the outset, making it an accessible option. However, a thicker 10-inch mattress might offer more excellent value over time, with its extended durability and increased comfort. 

Factors to Consider Before Choosing Between 8 Inch and 10 Inch Best Mattresses

Weight limit, firmness levels, and health benefits are important factors when deciding between an 8-inch and a 10-inch mattress. Learn how these factors can impact your decision-making process by reading more.

Consider the weight limit choosing mattress

Weight limit

Consider the weight limit when choosing between an 8-inch and a 10-inch mattress. An 8-inch mattress may be suitable for individuals of average weight, while plus-sized sleepers might prefer the additional support offered by a thicker 10-inch mattress.

The thickness of the mattress can impact its ability to comfortably accommodate different body types and distribute weight effectively, influencing overall comfort and quality of sleep.

Evaluating the weight capacity recommended for each mattress thickness is essential to ensure it aligns with individual needs.

Understanding the firmness levels of mattresse.

Firmness levels

An 8-inch mattress typically offers a firmer feel than its thicker counterpart, the 10-inch mattress. The thinner profile of an 8-inch mattress often provides more support and resilience, making it suitable for individuals who prefer a firmer sleeping surface.

On the other hand, a 10-inch mattress offers a balance between firmness and comfort due to its additional layers, making it ideal for those seeking a softer yet supportive sleeping experience.

Understanding the firmness levels of mattresses is crucial in determining which thickness best suits individual preferences and needs. The next factor worth considering is the impact of mattress thickness on health benefits and overall sleep quality.

Mattress Health benefits

Health benefits

An 8-inch memory foam mattress can offer health benefits, such as firm support for individuals with back pain. The firmer surface of an 8-inch mattress may promote proper spinal alignment, reducing discomfort and improving sleep quality.

On the other hand, a 10-inch mattress, with its thicker profile, provides additional cushioning and conformability that can alleviate pressure points and enhance blood circulation during sleep.

This may be particularly beneficial for homeowners seeking relief from joint pain or muscle tension.

Which Thickness is Best for You?

For single adults, a 10-inch mattress may provide better support and comfort, while couples or plus-sized sleepers might benefit from the additional thickness of a 10-inch mattress.

However, an 8-inch mattress may be sufficient for kids or guest rooms. Consider your specific needs and preferences when choosing the right thickness for your mattress.

Which Thickness is Best for single

For single adults

An 8-inch memory foam mattress might suit a single adult seeking a firmer sleeping surface. Being more cost-effective and lightweight, this type of mattress can be easily maneuvered and set up without much hassle.

However, plus-sized individuals may find a thicker option, such as a 10-inch mattress, to provide better support and comfort due to its additional thickness. It all depends on the individual’s preference for firmness and body weight when determining which is the better fit.

couples mattress thickness

For couples

Moving on from the considerations for single adults, selecting a mattress thickness suitable for couples involves finding a balance between comfort and support. A 10-inch mattress may offer better weight distribution and reduced motion transfer, providing added comfort for both partners during sleep.

Additionally, couples with varying firmness preferences can benefit from the versatility of a 10-inch mattress while still ensuring adequate support to accommodate different body weights.

Moreover, a thicker 10-inch memory foam mattress can provide enhanced durability and longevity under the combined weight of two individuals. With its ability to maintain its shape over time, this type of mattress could be an ideal choice for couples seeking long-lasting quality and support.

Mattress Thickness for kids

For kids

When shopping for a mattress for kids, it’s important to consider their weight and comfort needs. An 8-inch mattress can be suitable for most children, providing adequate support while being lighter and more cost-effective.

However, parents of plus-sized or older children may consider a thicker 10-inch mattress to ensure proper comfort and support as they grow.

The firmness level of the mattress is also crucial for kids’ developing bodies. Thinner mattresses, like an 8-inch option, typically come firmer, which might benefit younger children who need extra support.

For guest rooms

For guest rooms, the choice between an 8-inch and a 10-inch mattress depends on the specific needs of your guests. An 8-inch mattress could provide adequate comfort for occasional use, especially if the room is not used frequently.

It also offers a more budget-friendly option, which can be beneficial when outfitting multiple guest rooms in a home or rental property.

A 10-inch mattress may offer additional comfort and support for guests staying longer. Its thicker profile could contribute to a more luxurious feel, making it suitable for regular use in guest accommodations.

Is 8 inches thick enough for a mattress?

For guest rooms where space may be limited, an 8-inch mattress could be sufficient. The slimmer profile allows for easier maneuverability and transportation, making it ideal for guest accommodations.

Additionally, the cost-effectiveness of an 8-inch mattress without compromising on quality makes it a practical choice for occasional use.

Slimmer mattresses like the 8-inch one can provide adequate support and comfort, particularly for single sleepers or individuals with petite frames. The firmer feel of an 8-inch memory foam mattress might also appeal to those who prefer more robust sleeping surfaces. This will help you know how thick a mattress should be and whether it fits your mattress type preference or not.

Is a 10-inch mattress too thin?

Transitioning from discussing the suitability of an 8-inch mattress to exploring the thinness of a 10-inch mattress, it’s important to consider the preferences and needs of different individuals.

A 10-inch mattress may be perceived as too thin for those seeking a more substantial sleeping surface, especially if they need extra support or have larger body frames. Additionally, some sleepers might find that a 10-inch mattress does not provide enough cushioning, especially if they desire a plusher feel.

However, a 10-inch mattress could offer adequate comfort and proper spinal alignment for individuals who prefer firmer support or have smaller body frames. As such, assessing personal preferences and individual requirements is crucial when determining whether a 10-inch average mattress is too thin. While doing all these calculations, consider the mattress topper’s thickness when choosing a mattress.

Is a 10-inch thick mattress good?

Considering the thickness and support, a 10-inch mattress offers a good balance for many sleepers. Its additional thickness may provide enhanced comfort and adequate support, especially for those who prefer a slightly softer sleeping surface.

With its thicker profile, a 10-inch mattress can accommodate different body weights and sizes, offering better pressure relief and spinal alignment. Additionally, the extra padding or the extra thick padding in a 10-inch mattress can contribute to minimizing motion transfer, making it an ideal choice for couples or individuals who move frequently during sleep.

Furthermore, the increased depth of a 10-inch mattress allows for more layers with varying materials that can offer improved breathability and temperature regulation. This could provide a cooler sleeping environment by allowing better air circulation through the added layers of foam or other materials used in its construction.

Pros and Cons of 8 Inch and 10 Inch Mattresses

The decision between an 8-inch and a 10-inch mattress involves weighing various advantages and disadvantages tailored to individual preferences and needs. Homeowners stand to benefit from understanding the nuanced differences between the two options.

Pros of 8 Inch Mattresses:

– Cost-effective: Typically more affordable, an 8-inch mattress offers a budget-friendly option without significantly compromising on comfort.

– Suitable for a firmer feel: Often firmer due to less cushioning, it can be ideal for those who prefer a solid sleep surface.

– Lightweight design: The thinner profile makes it easier to move and handle, simplifying transport and setup.

– Compatibility: Works well with bunk beds and trundle beds, given its thinner construction.

– Adequate for lighter individuals: It provides sufficient support for petite or lightweight sleepers who don’t need extra padding.

Cons of 8 Inch Mattresses:

– Limited cushioning: This may not provide enough pressure relief for some sleepers, especially side sleepers and those with joint pain.

– Potentially less durable: Thinner mattresses might have a shorter lifespan than their thicker counterparts.

– Insufficient for heavier individuals: Might not offer the necessary support and comfort for plus-sized sleepers.

Pros of 10 Inch Mattresses:

– Enhanced comfort: The added thickness allows for more layers of material, often resulting in improved comfort and better pressure relief.

– Versatile support: Can accommodate a broader range of body weights and sleeping positions.

– Longer lifespan: Generally more durable, a 10-inch mattress might maintain its shape and support for a more extended period.

– A balanced choice: Presents a good compromise between a slim profile and a plush feel, making it an excellent middle-ground option.

Cons of 10 Inch Mattresses:

– Higher cost: More material and additional layers mean a 10-inch mattress is usually more expensive than an 8-inch one.

– Heavier and bulkier: The increased thickness makes the mattress heavier, which might be a concern when moving or changing bed linens.

– Potentially too soft for some: Some sleepers may find a 10-inch mattress too plush, particularly those who require a firmer sleeping surface for back support.

Both 8-inch and 10-inch mattresses provide distinct experiences to homeowners, making the choice largely dependent on personal preference, budget, and specific sleeping requirements. Whether it’s an 8-inch mattress’s firmness or the 10-inch plush comfort, the right mattress thickness is pivotal for restful sleep.

Conclusion – To Choose A Mattress Based On Your Needs

When selecting between 8-inch and 10-inch mattresses, consider weight limits, firmness levels, and health benefits. Thinner mattresses like the 8-inch provide firmer support, while thicker ones like the 10-inch offer enhanced comfort.

For single adults or guest rooms, an 8-inch mattress might suffice. However, couples or plus-sized individuals may prefer the added thickness of a 10-inch mattress for optimal comfort and support.

Understanding individual needs and preferences is key to selecting the best mattress thickness option for quality sleep.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the differences between an 8-inch and a 10-inch mattress?

An 8-inch mattress is thinner than a 10-inch one, providing less depth and support.

Can I use standard bed sheets for 8- and 10-inch mattresses?

Yes, standard bed sheets can fit 8- and 10-inch mattresses without issues.

Is there a significant difference in comfort between an 8-inch and a 10-inch mattress?

A thicker mattress, such as the 10-inch, provides more cushioning and support than an 8-inch counterpart.

Do I need to purchase special frames or foundations for either the 8 or the 10-inch mattresses?

Both mattresses are typically used with standard bed frames or box springs without special accommodations.

Is a 10-inch thick mattress good?

A 10-inch thick mattress can provide good support and comfort for most people, especially those who prefer a higher bed. It can offer ample cushioning and be suitable for side and back sleepers. However, individuals with specific health concerns or body types may need a different thickness to ensure proper alignment and support.


Stephani (she/her) serves as the Executive Director of Strategy and Operations at, where she conducts comprehensive research, testing, and analysis of fabric-based products spanning sheets, mattresses, towels, pillows, fitness apparel, and other clothing items..Read more

No Comments Yet

Comments are closed